A Reddit user took to the r/Anticonsumption community to share a photo that perfectly captures the packaging paradox facing consumers.

What's happening?

The image shows promotional material from Oceana, a large conservation group. Ironically, the pamphlet warning that "33 billion pounds of plastic enter the oceans every year" came sealed in the same material it urges consumers to avoid.

One commenter summarized the situation perfectly, writing, "At what point does irony slip over into travesty and tragedy?"

In a statement to The Cool Down, a spokesperson for Oceana said it is "committed to reducing unnecessary single-use plastics and ending plastic pollution in our oceans" and that "the magazine in question was not produced by Oceana; it is Foreign Affairs magazine." The spokesperson said that "Foreign Affairs generously donated ad space in a recent issue, but we were not aware it was distributed in plastic packaging" and that "we have since reached out to Foreign Affairs, expressed our concerns, and encouraged them to consider alternative packaging."

Why is excessive packaging concerning?

Many companies tout environmental commitments while wrapping their products in hard-to-recycle packaging. The burden falls on consumers to figure out disposal methods, sowing frustration and wasting time.

In many households, these materials pile up fast. Junk mail alone creates about 5.6 million tons of waste in the U.S. every year, according to the group Senior Stewards Acting for the Environment. Many of these pieces of mail come with plastic wrappers that often can't be processed in standard recycling programs.

Financially, consumers pay for excessive packaging twice: first, for the higher product costs (packaging materials aren't free) and, second, for waste management fees and environmental cleanup costs through taxes and utility bills.

Is Oceana doing anything about this?

Oceana has many campaigns dedicated to reducing plastic pollution, making this packaging choice unfortunate and surprising, though as the spokesperson said, it was a choice made by another entity that Oceana was not aware of until after it went out. The organization advocates for policies that reduce single-use plastics and works to protect marine ecosystems from plastic pollution.

On its website, Oceana states that it has helped secure policies that would eliminate the use of 1.61 million tons of single-use plastic annually by 2033, which the spokesperson noted would be equivalent to about 146 million plastic bottles). The organization advocates for laws that would make companies, not consumers, responsible for managing packaging waste.

"Following years of campaigning by Oceana, in 2024, Amazon phased out the use of plastic air pillows in its delivery packaging globally," the spokesperson cited.

What confuses you most about recycling protocol? Which materials I can recycle 📦 How clean the material needs to be 🧼 What the plastic numbers mean ♻️ Nothing at all 😇 Click your choice to see results and speak your mind.

This incident demonstrates how many organizations struggle to align all aspects with their sustainability goals, especially when collaborating with other companies.

What's being done about excessive packaging more broadly?

Several companies lead by example with innovative packaging solutions. Retailers such as Lush have created "naked" packaging for many products, while others use compostable materials.

Maine and Oregon have passed strict recycling laws, requiring companies to pay fees based on the amount and recyclability of packaging they use. These fees fund improvements to recycling programs and push companies to reduce packaging waste.

Consumers can help by supporting companies with minimal packaging, contacting businesses about packaging concerns, shopping in person when possible, signing petitions supporting better packaging laws, and looking for products with clear disposal instructions.

Editor's note: This article was updated to include statements from an Oceana spokesperson.

Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.